Skip to main content
HomeSpecialistsBusinessBlogContact us
العربيةFor care providersBook a session
Skip to article text

Core beliefs: how to reconsider a harsh judgment about yourself

Fahad AlmalikMedical review: Tatmeen team7 min read
امرأة تمسك مرآتين؛ إحداهما تظهر وجهًا مشوه الملامح والأخرى تظهر وجهها بابتسامة.
Article contents
  1. From “I didn't understand” to “I'm incapable”
  2. Notice the present
  3. A small experiment tests a prediction, not your worth
  4. How can you begin changing a longstanding judgment?
  5. When to stop and seek support
  6. Frequently Asked Questions
  7. Sources and references
  8. Writer and reviewer

A small event can become a large judgment: you struggle with a task and conclude “I'm incompetent”, or a friend declines a meeting and you conclude “Nobody wants me”. These judgments reach beyond the immediate event. In the cognitive model, deep, general judgments about yourself, other people or the world are called core beliefs. They may be treated as facts6, although they need to be considered against evidence and context1.

Look at what the judgment leads you to do today. You might avoid asking a question because not understanding feels like a personal flaw, or withdraw a request because you expect rejection. Reconsidering a belief starts by making room for another response; you do not have to settle its origins first.

A belief might also concern other people6: “Nobody can be trusted.” It may lead you to refuse help you need, even from someone who has treated you respectfully. Consider this person and situation: what do you know about their behavior, and what boundaries protect you? Reconsidering a generalization does not require trusting everyone or dismissing harm that actually occurred.

From “I didn't understand” to “I'm incapable”

Three levels can appear in the same situation:

Level Illustrative example
Thought about a situation “I didn't understand that explanation”
Rule or assumption “If I admit I didn't understand, they'll see me as incapable”
Broader self-judgment “I'm incapable”

A thought concerns the immediate situation, a rule predicts what a particular action will lead to, and the belief makes a broader judgment about yourself. The Centre for Clinical Interventions distinguishes broad negative beliefs from rules and assumptions guiding behaviour2, although terminology can vary between therapy models.

In a training session, for example, “I'm incapable” might lead you to stay silent when a step is unclear. It remains unclear, and you interpret the continuing difficulty as more evidence of being incapable. Avoiding the question can cost you an opportunity to learn3 and leave the judgment intact. Asking for clarification in a safe setting gives you a chance to understand or identify what needs practice, even while you still doubt your ability.

Beliefs, behaviour and circumstances can affect each other. A belief is not a key that explains your whole life. Missing training, an unsupportive workplace and other people's harmful behaviour are real factors; treating yourself as the sole cause will not resolve them.

Notice the present

Choose an ordinary event you can recall clearly and complete two sentences:

  • “After … happened, I said about myself …”.
  • “Because of that judgment, I did … or avoided …”.

Write what you actually recall, without searching for a hidden judgment behind every event. There may be no broad belief to identify. If you notice a harsh statement, consider how it affected your response. Feeling strongly convinced or distressed does not settle whether it is true.

A small experiment tests a prediction, not your worth

A behavioural experiment compares a specific prediction3 with an observable outcome. CCI describes this within a sequential self-esteem programme. The following example is a limited learning suggestion, not a stand-alone treatment programme.

Return to the training example. If you expect the trainer to mock you, you could ask in a safe setting: “Could you explain how you got from this step to the next?” Then compare the prediction with what happens:

Before Afterwards
Prediction: “If I ask about this step, the trainer will call the question stupid” Record what they actually said or did
Action: Ask one question about the unclear step Did they explain it, postpone it, or respond unkindly?
Boundary: An ordinary question in a setting that allows questions, without risking safety or employment What did you learn about this situation, and what response fits?

An ordinary answer provides information about that prediction in this setting; it does not mean everyone will respond similarly. An unkind answer need not be made to look positive. You can acknowledge it and seek another way to learn or obtain support. An ambiguous answer may leave the prediction unresolved. None of these outcomes determines your worth as a person.

Do not test a belief by confronting someone harmful, dropping a sensible health precaution, disclosing private information or deliberately making a consequential mistake. Do not repeatedly ask others to confirm that you are good. The task is to learn something specific about an observable situation.

How can you begin changing a longstanding judgment?

“I can learn this skill, and I'll need clarification and practice” may fit the evidence better than “I'm incapable”. It makes room for asking and practising while acknowledging that you have not mastered the skill yet. You do not have to replace a harsh judgment with praise you cannot believe.

After asking one question, what you learned may be modest: “I asked for clarification and understood this step better.” Give that information its due3 instead of dismissing it as “It was easy, so it doesn't count.” Keep track of what still needs practice too. A more accurate judgment can include both ability and difficulty.

A longstanding harsh judgment may take time and support to change. You can begin with a different response before a new belief feels fully convincing.

When to stop and seek support

Put the exercise aside if it brings up painful memories, increases distress or leads to repeated investigation of yourself. You do not have to excavate childhood or repeatedly ask “What does this mean about me?” until you reach a hurtful answer. If these judgments affect your life1, a clinician can help you understand them4 and choose a suitable approach.

If experiments or evidence checking become rituals for obtaining certainty, particularly with obsessions, tell the clinician5 rather than repeating them more intensely. This page does not provide OCD treatment.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are core beliefs?

In the cognitive model, core beliefs are deep, general judgments about yourself, other people or the world. A small event can become a large judgment: you struggle with a task and conclude “I'm incompetent”. These judgments reach beyond the immediate event and may be treated as facts, although they need to be considered against evidence and context. To understand a judgment's effect, look at what it leads you to do today.

What is the difference between a thought, a rule and a core belief?

All three can appear in the same situation. A thought concerns the immediate situation: “I didn't understand that explanation.” A rule predicts what a particular action will lead to: “If I admit I didn't understand, they'll see me as incapable.” The belief makes a broader judgment about yourself: “I'm incapable.” Terminology can vary between therapy models.

How can I change a harsh judgment about myself?

Begin with a different response before a new belief feels fully convincing. “I can learn this skill, and I'll need clarification and practice” may fit the evidence better than “I'm incapable”, because it makes room for asking and practising. You do not have to replace a harsh judgment with praise you cannot believe. Give what you learn its due, even if modest, and keep track of what still needs practice. A longstanding judgment may take time and support to change.

What is a behavioural experiment?

A behavioural experiment compares a specific prediction with an observable outcome. If you expect a trainer to mock you, you could ask one question about an unclear step in a safe setting, then compare the prediction with what they actually said or did. Do not test a belief by confronting someone harmful, dropping a sensible health precaution or disclosing private information. Whatever the outcome, it does not determine your worth as a person.

When should I get professional help with harsh judgments about myself?

Put the exercise aside if it brings up painful memories, increases distress or leads to repeated investigation of yourself; you do not have to excavate childhood until you reach a hurtful answer. If these judgments affect your life, a clinician can help you understand them and choose a suitable approach. If experiments or evidence checking become rituals for obtaining certainty, particularly with obsessions, tell the clinician rather than repeating them more intensely.

Writing and article review

Fahad AlmalikWritten byFahad Almalik

Content writer and researcher at Tatmeen, writing in Arabic and English about mental health and everyday life, from relationships and stress to work, habits, and family.

Tatmeen teamMedical reviewTatmeen team

Every Tatmeen article is reviewed by care providers licensed by the Saudi Commission for Health Specialties, so what you read is accurate and trustworthy.

How we write and reviewSpotted an error? Tell us

This article builds understanding and does not replace a licensed care provider.

Need someone to talk to?

Tatmeen's licensed care providers are available around the clock, and the app's urgent consultation connects you with one within minutes.

Talk to a care provider

In immediate danger?

If you or someone you know is in danger, call an ambulance on 997 or go to the nearest emergency department.

Emergency numbers

Was this article helpful?

Add us to Google
All articles

Talk to a care provider

Your session, remotely and your way: voice, video or text.

  • Licensed by the Saudi Commission for Health Specialties
  • Available around the clock
  • Complete privacy and confidentiality
All care providers

One step for you, start now

Download Tatmeen to explore care providers and booking options.

  • Smart matchingFour quick questions suggest the right care provider
  • Urgent consultationTalk to an available care provider within minutes
  • Free psychological measuresMore than 20 tests to understand how you are doing

Scan to download