Skip to main content
HomeSpecialistsBusinessBlogContact us
العربيةFor care providersBook a session
Skip to article text

Child discipline without hitting: teaching your child to put mistakes right

Alanoud AlturkiMedical review: Tatmeen team6 min read
امرأة محجبة تجلس أمام طفل، وخلفهما رسم أحمر للتوبيخ ورسم أخضر لحديث هادئ.
Article contents
  1. What do they need to learn here?
  2. Keep repair connected to the mistake
  3. Teach an alternative and allow disappointment
  4. When you lose your temper
  5. Frequently Asked Questions
  6. Sources and references
  7. Writer and reviewer

Your child draws on the table after you asked them to use paper. You can stop the drawing, bring over a sheet and help clean the mark. That response shows them where to draw and what to do after a mistake. “How many times have I told you?” may end the conversation, but it does not show them the next step.

Stop any harm first, then choose something your child can learn or help repair. Discipline does not require hitting, humiliation or frightening threats. WHO documents the harms of physical punishment1, and the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends nonviolent teaching2 and rules children can understand.

What do they need to learn here?

Spilling water while carrying a cup is different from throwing it at a sibling. The first may call for a lighter cup or practice. In the second, remove the cup and protect the sibling, then teach a way to object without hurting anyone. You do not need to know everything the child was thinking before stopping danger.

Afterwards, look at the request. Do they know where the materials belong? Can they put them away? Did they hear you while absorbed in something else? Name the action: “Put the pencils in the box” or “Return it to its owner.” “Behave yourself” leaves them guessing what you mean.

A child may know a rule and still need help applying it. Repeating the words does not mean they have mastered the skill in every situation. With a young child, demonstrate, use few words and arrange the surroundings to reduce danger. With a school-age child, discuss what happened and what they could do differently once things are calm. There is no single age at which every child understands every rule2.

Keep repair connected to the mistake

Every mishap does not need a separate punishment. These responses address what happened and give the child a manageable part:

Situation What you can do together
Drawing on the table Stop drawing there and provide paper. Help clean the mark with a safe tool the child can use.
Throwing a hard toy Remove it while its use is dangerous. Show a safe way to play, such as pushing a car along the floor or throwing a soft ball in a suitable space.
Taking something without permission Return it, then practise asking permission and waiting for an answer.
Leaving activity materials scattered Start with a clear share: “You collect the paper; I'll collect the crayons,” before bringing out another activity.

Help or reduce the task when it exceeds the child's ability. An adult handles broken glass and other hazards. Taking part in repair should never mean facing a danger alone or being given work they cannot do.

If you stop a toy or activity, explain why and what comes next: “The car stays here because throwing it hurts people. We can try it on the floor when you can use it safely.” Long restrictions that bundle together a week's mistakes make the connection harder to understand. Never withdraw food, medication, sleep or essential care because of behaviour. The AAP specifically warns against taking away something a child needs2, such as a meal.

Teach an alternative and allow disappointment

You might say, “I won't let you throw the car at anyone. You can say, 'I'm still playing.'” Once they are calm, practise the request in a simple situation. When they use it later, describe what you noticed: “You said you were still playing instead of throwing the car.” They can then recognise the action you want them to repeat.

A child may comply while frowning or saying they dislike tidying. If they are not hurting anyone, being upset does not need another punishment. Avoid demanding “Sorry” just to make the incident look resolved. Help them understand the impact, make an appropriate repair and learn what an apology means.

When the mistake recurs, look for the part they find difficult. A younger child might need a clearer drawing space; a school-age child might need a regular place for materials. Choose one recurring problem and agree on a request and response with other caregivers. A small agreement you can follow is more useful than a long list nobody keeps up with.

When you lose your temper

An argument may catch you rushing or exhausted. Stop the exchange if you feel close to hurting your child, and ask a trusted adult to take over if possible. If you are alone, make sure the child is safe and appropriately supervised while you take a moment to settle. Do not shake them or shut them somewhere frightening.

If you shouted, repair your approach while keeping the limit: “I shouted at you. I should have spoken calmly. We'll clean the table together, and drawing goes on paper.” Children also need to see how an adult returns to a mistake2 and tries again.

Seek professional support if harm keeps recurring, sleep, school or relationships are affected, or you fear you may hurt your child. Bring examples of what happens, what comes before it and what helps. You do not need a ready-made diagnosis or a worsening situation before asking.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I discipline my child without hitting?

Stop any harm first, then show your child what to do instead and help them repair what they can. If they draw on the table, for example, stop the drawing, bring over paper and help clean the mark. Discipline does not require hitting, humiliation or frightening threats. WHO documents the harms of physical punishment, and the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends nonviolent teaching and rules children can understand.

Is it OK to take away food or sleep as a punishment?

No. Never withdraw food, medication, sleep or essential care because of behaviour. The American Academy of Pediatrics specifically warns against taking away something a child needs, such as a meal. If you stop a toy or activity, explain why and what comes next. Long restrictions that bundle together a week's mistakes make the connection harder for your child to understand.

Should I make my child say sorry?

Avoid demanding “Sorry” just to make the incident look resolved. Instead, help your child understand the impact of what they did, make an appropriate repair and learn what an apology means. They may comply while frowning or saying they dislike tidying; if they are not hurting anyone, being upset does not need another punishment.

What should I do if I lose my temper with my child?

If you feel close to hurting your child, stop the exchange and ask a trusted adult to take over if possible. If you are alone, make sure the child is safe and appropriately supervised while you take a moment to settle. Do not shake them or shut them somewhere frightening. If you shouted, repair your approach while keeping the limit: “I shouted at you. I should have spoken calmly.”

When should I seek professional help with discipline at home?

Seek professional support if harm keeps recurring, if sleep, school or relationships are affected, or if you fear you may hurt your child. Bring examples of what happens, what comes before it and what helps. You do not need a ready-made diagnosis, or to wait for the situation to get worse, before asking.

Writing and article review

Alanoud AlturkiWritten byAlanoud Alturki

Content writer and researcher at Tatmeen, writing in Arabic and English on mental health and everyday life topics, including relationships, stress, work, habits, and family.

Tatmeen teamMedical reviewTatmeen team

Every Tatmeen article is reviewed by care providers licensed by the Saudi Commission for Health Specialties, so what you read is accurate and trustworthy.

How we write and reviewSpotted an error? Tell us

This article builds understanding and does not replace a licensed care provider.

Need someone to talk to?

Tatmeen's licensed care providers are available around the clock, and the app's urgent consultation connects you with one within minutes.

Talk to a care provider

In immediate danger?

If you or someone you know is in danger, call an ambulance on 997 or go to the nearest emergency department.

Emergency numbers

Was this article helpful?

Add us to Google
All articles

Talk to a care provider

Your session, remotely and your way: voice, video or text.

  • Licensed by the Saudi Commission for Health Specialties
  • Available around the clock
  • Complete privacy and confidentiality
All care providers

One step for you, start now

Download Tatmeen to explore care providers and booking options.

  • Smart matchingFour quick questions suggest the right care provider
  • Urgent consultationTalk to an available care provider within minutes
  • Free psychological measuresMore than 20 tests to understand how you are doing

Scan to download