Skip to main content
HomeSpecialistsBusinessBlogContact us
العربيةFor care providersBook a session
Skip to article text

Sibling jealousy: fairness, attention and handling disagreements

Fahad AlmalikMedical review: Tatmeen team7 min read
طفل عابس يجلس بعيدًا، بينما امرأة تحمل رضيعًا وتجلس بجوارها طفلة قرب مائدة صغيرة.
Article contents
  1. Sometimes the objection makes sense
  2. A safe disagreement needs a manageable solution
  3. Make room for the older child when a baby arrives
  4. Fairness can reflect different needs
  5. When one child becomes afraid of another
  6. Frequently Asked Questions
  7. Sources and references
  8. Writer and reviewer

“You care about them more than me.” Your child may say this while you hold the new baby, or after a dispute over a toy or a place beside you. Before replying, “I love you both equally,” listen to what they mean this time. Have they been waiting for time with you? Has their sibling taken a personal belonging? Do they feel expected to give in every time?

You do not have to prove your fairness in one sentence. Let them speak, then respond to the need that emerges. If a child is hitting or frightening another, stop the harm and separate them safely first. Jealousy does not oblige a sibling to tolerate harm.

Sometimes the objection makes sense

A younger child might enter an older sibling's room and scribble in their notebook, leaving the older child to hear, “They're little; let it go.” Their belonging needs protection too. Return the notebook, help the younger child find their own paper and keep personal items somewhere they cannot reach without permission. Preventing the younger child's tears is not the older child's sole responsibility.

If you do not know what bothered them, ask about the situation: “What happened?” or “Tell me what bothered you.” “You're always jealous” turns a changeable problem into a judgment about the child.

The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommends clear limits, listening suited to each child's age and abilities, and intervention when physical or emotional wellbeing is affected1. Hearing both sides matters, but it follows stopping harm. It does not make both children equally responsible for every incident.

A safe disagreement needs a manageable solution

When both children can talk and nobody is at risk, give them a brief chance to find a solution. If they need you, hear each without interruptions from the other, then name the concrete problem: “You both want the toy now” or “You entered their room without permission.”

For a shared toy, agree on a turn with an understandable ending, or find another activity. A personal belonging does not have to be shared whenever a sibling asks. Some things can be shared while others require permission. If the younger child cannot yet wait, help and provide an alternative. An agreement depending on an unlearned skill will not sustain itself.

Once things are calm, help repair the result: return the item or help put right the mess, within the child's ability. Avoid forcing a hug or apology to make the children appear reconciled. They may need separate time before wanting a shared activity.

Make room for the older child when a baby arrives

Family language may turn a child into “the big one” overnight, while they still have small everyday needs for your care. Explain the change: “The baby needs help eating and sleeping, and you need my time too.” AAP guidance stresses keeping the older child's activities and individual time2 in view after a baby's arrival.

If you are feeding the baby alone, you may not be able to stop immediately. Offer what you can actually do: “Come and sit beside me. Show me the book you chose. When I'm finished, I'll listen to the rest of the story.” Return to their request when you can, without making another argument the only way to remind you. A trusted adult might help care for the baby so you can have time together, if that support is available.

Keep a small familiar activity together. A story or bedtime conversation is more useful than a big promise repeatedly postponed. The child can choose a small helping task, such as bringing an item of clothing. Baby care must not become their job, and a young child should not be left with the baby without supervision.

If they say, “I don't love the baby,” ask what feels difficult or say, “You can tell me you're upset. I'll keep both of you safe.” You do not need to extract a declaration of love. The boundary is about harm, not requiring a feeling of your choosing.

Fairness can reflect different needs

Different treatment is not always favouritism1, but explaining it helps: “I'm helping your brother because he can't do this yet. I'll help with what you need too.” Watch for “You understand more” becoming a reason their turn is always delayed.

State the request without comparison: “Put your bag in its place,” rather than “Why can't you be like your sister?” Offer individual attention you can keep up, and let each child have their own space, belongings and interests. They do not have to play together all day for their relationship to be good.

When one child becomes afraid of another

Repeated threats, humiliation or hitting, fear of being with a sibling, or changes affecting sleep, school and participation at home call for professional support. Consider differences in age and strength rather than counting each child's angry moments. Arrange medical care for an injury according to its severity, and put protective supervision in place before trying to repair the relationship.

Resolving a disagreement can take time. Protection is your responsibility now, even as you listen to the child who caused harm.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I say when my child says I care about their sibling more?

Before replying, “I love you both equally,” listen to what they mean this time. They may have been waiting for time with you, their sibling may have taken a personal belonging, or they may feel expected to give in every time. Let them speak, then respond to the need that emerges. If you do not know what bothered them, ask: “What happened?” Calling them “always jealous” turns a changeable problem into a judgment.

How do I handle siblings fighting over a toy?

If one child is hitting or frightening the other, stop the harm and separate them safely first. When both children can talk and nobody is at risk, give them a brief chance to find a solution. If they need you, hear each without interruptions, then name the problem. For a shared toy, agree on a turn with an understandable ending. A personal belonging does not have to be shared whenever a sibling asks.

How can I help my older child adjust to a new baby?

Keep their activities and time with you in view: they still have small everyday needs for your care. Explain the change: “The baby needs help eating and sleeping, and you need my time too.” Keep a small familiar activity, such as a bedtime story, rather than a big promise repeatedly postponed. They can help with a small task, but baby care must not become their job, and a young child should not be left with the baby unsupervised.

Is treating siblings differently a sign of favouritism?

Different treatment is not always favouritism, but explaining it helps: “I'm helping your brother because he can't do this yet. I'll help with what you need too.” Watch for “You understand more” becoming a reason one child's turn is always delayed. State requests without comparison, offer individual attention you can keep up, and let each child have their own space, belongings and interests.

When does sibling conflict need professional help?

Repeated threats, humiliation or hitting, fear of being with a sibling, or changes affecting sleep, school and participation at home call for professional support. Consider differences in age and strength rather than counting each child's angry moments. Arrange medical care for an injury according to its severity, and put protective supervision in place before trying to repair the relationship. Protection is your responsibility now, even as you listen to the child who caused harm.

Writing and article review

Fahad AlmalikWritten byFahad Almalik

Content writer and researcher at Tatmeen, writing in Arabic and English about mental health and everyday life, from relationships and stress to work, habits, and family.

Tatmeen teamMedical reviewTatmeen team

Every Tatmeen article is reviewed by care providers licensed by the Saudi Commission for Health Specialties, so what you read is accurate and trustworthy.

How we write and reviewSpotted an error? Tell us

This article builds understanding and does not replace a licensed care provider.

Need someone to talk to?

Tatmeen's licensed care providers are available around the clock, and the app's urgent consultation connects you with one within minutes.

Talk to a care provider

In immediate danger?

If you or someone you know is in danger, call an ambulance on 997 or go to the nearest emergency department.

Emergency numbers

Was this article helpful?

Add us to Google
All articles

Talk to a care provider

Your session, remotely and your way: voice, video or text.

  • Licensed by the Saudi Commission for Health Specialties
  • Available around the clock
  • Complete privacy and confidentiality
All care providers

One step for you, start now

Download Tatmeen to explore care providers and booking options.

  • Smart matchingFour quick questions suggest the right care provider
  • Urgent consultationTalk to an available care provider within minutes
  • Free psychological measuresMore than 20 tests to understand how you are doing

Scan to download